Our Menu
7 AM - 11:30 AM • *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Egg Sandwiches
Add Extra Egg +$3.09 • Add Meat: Bacon, Sausage, Ham, or Turkey +$3.09 • Add Cheese: American
, Swiss, Mozzarella, or Cheddar +$1.03
Egg Sandwich
$6.18
Omelets
All omelet's come with home fries and a choice of toast: Wheat, White, Rye, or Multigrain • Bagel $2.06 or English muffin $1.55
Cheese Omelet
$18.54
Western Omelet
$19.57
Stuff a Omelette
$22.66
Add Meat +$3.09 • Add Cheese +$1.03• Add up to 3 Veggies: Spinach, Broccoli, Mushroom, Tomatoes, Onions
Egg Platters
Platters Come with Home Fries & Choice of Toast: White, Wheat, Rye or Multigrain • Bagel or English muffin $1.03 | Any Meat +$2.32
One Egg Any Style
$9.27
Two Eggs Any Style
$13.39
Nicky's Favorites
Breakfast Burrito
$19.57
Eggs, beans, cheese, salsa, home fries.
French Toast
$17.51
Powdered sugar, butter, and syrup.
Avocado Toast
$15.45
Add everything seeds or hot sauce.
Pancakes
$18.54
Add Berries, Bananas or Chocolate Chips +$2.06
Avocado Toast with Smoked Salmon
$25.75
Famous Donuts
$1.80
Sides / Extras
Muffin
$4.12
Avocado
$6.18
Home Fries
$6.18
Side of any Meat
$6.18
English Muffin
$3.09
Bagel
$5.15
Smoked Salmon
$12.36
Roll
$3.09
Cup of Fruit
$7.21
Toast
$1.54
Multigrain Toast
$2.06
Homemade Soups
Manhattan Clam Chowder
$7.21/+
Tomato-based chowder full of vegetables, chopped clams, bacon & potatoes • Cup $7.21 | Bowl $9.01
Clam Bisque
$7.21/+
Creamy New England-style clam chowder without potatoes • Cup $7.21 | Bowl $9.01
Corn Chowder
$7.21/+
Creamy corn soup with vegetables • Cup $7.21 | Bowl $9.01
Nicky’s Famous Seafood Bisque
$10.04/+
Bright pink creamy soup loaded with chunks of real lobster, crab & shrimp • Cup $10.04 | Bowl $12.87
Vegetarian Minestrone
$7.21/+
Mixed vegetable soup with a touch of fresh parmesan • Cup $7.21 | Bowl $9.01
Cream of Asparagus with Crabmeat
$10.04/+
Seasonal • Cup $10.04 | Bowl $12.10
Spicy Lentil with Italian Sausage
$7.21/+
Slightly Spicy | Lentil soup with vegetables, fresh parmesan, and Italian sausage • Cup $7.21 | Bowl $9.01
Soup of the Day
$7.21/+
Ask your server for the Soup of the Day • Cup $7.21 | Bowl $9.01
Garden Fresh Salads
Add Grilled Shrimp (3) +$14.32 | Grilled Chicken +$6.37 | Grilled Salmon +$7.72 | Sesame Seared Tuna +$9.27 • Homemade Dressings: Bleu Cheese, Thousand Island, Creamy Garlic, Citrus Vinaigrette Red French Onion & Balsamic Vinaigrette, Red Wine Vinaigrette • Also Available: Creamy Ranch, Caesar, Raspberry Vinaigrette & Honey Mustard
Garden Salad
$13.39
Mixed greens with fresh vegetables.
Caesar Salad
$15.96
Chopped romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese & creamy Caesar dressing.
Greek Salad
$18.02
Mixed greens with feta cheese, onions, peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, kalamata olives & pita bread.
Nicky's Arugula Salad
$18.02
Goat cheese, walnuts, chickpeas, avocado, tomatoes and dried cranberries with homemade citrus vinaigrette.
Seafood Cobb Salad
$32.96
Romaine, fresh shrimp cocktail, lump crabmeat, bacon, scallions, bleu cheese crumble with homemade bleu cheese ranch.
Nicky's Barges
The small plate of our fresh fried seafood • With your choice of one side for an extra $4.63: Coleslaw | Potato Salad | Side Salad | French Fries | Cajun Fries | Sweet Potato Fries | Onion Rings • Add Fried Shrimp (1) +$5.66
Clam Barge
$18.28
Whole belly top neck clams.
Oyster Barge
$20.86
Shrimp Barge (4)
$23.43
Flounder Barge
$19.83
Bay Scallop Barge
$19.31
From the Cold/Raw Bar
Clams on the 1/2 Shell
$10.04/+
Choice of: Little Neck, Top Neck, Cherry Stone • 1/2 Dozen $10.04 | Dozen $17.51
Local Harvested Oysters
$18.28/+
1/2 Dozen $18.28 | Dozen $30.38
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4)
$23.69/Dozen
Jumbo chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
Lump Crabmeat Cocktail
$24.72/Dozen
Served with cocktail sauce.
Nicky's Cold Combo
$39.14/Dozen
4 clams, 4 oysters & 4 jumbo shrimp cocktail.
Hot Starters
Clams Casino
$12.10/+
Baked Little Neck or Top Neck clams with bread crumbs & bacon • 1/2 Dozen $12.10 | Dozen $20.34
Clams Oreganata
$12.10/+
Baked Little Neck or Top Neck clams with garlic bread crumbs • 1/2 Dozen $12.10 | Dozen $20.34
Steamed Clams
$12.10/+
Little Neck or Top Neck clams steamed in white wine & garlic sauce, served with warm French bread • 1/2 Dozen $12.10 | Dozen $20.34
Bleu Cheese Florentine Oysters
$20.34/+
Long Island Sound diver harvested oysters topped with melted bleu cheese with bacon, spinach and garlic breadcrumbs • 1/2 Dozen $20.34 | Dozen $31.67
Baked Stuffed Clams
$15.45
Three large chopped stuffed clams.
Crab Cakes
$15.75
Two Maryland-style crab cakes served over a bed of coleslaw with Texas petal sauce.
Fried Calamari
$18.54
Lightly fried with choice of: Original | Spicy Buffalo | Spicy Hot Cherry Pepper Marinara | Sweet & Sour Chili Sauce
Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6)
$7.72
Served with homemade marinara sauce.
Mussels
$17.51/+
Served with warm bread | Choice of: White wine & Garlic | Marinara | Bleu Cheese Sauce with Bacon, Sundried Tomatoes and Scallions | Original Porky Style! - Garlic butter sherry wine sauce with carrots, celery & onions • Half $17.51 | Full $23.69
Nicky’s Famous Steamers
MKT
Tastiest steamers on the island cooked with garlic, celery & caraway seeds, served with drawn butter.
Nicky’s Chicken Wings
$16.48
On-The-Bone or Boneless | Tossed in a choice of: Spicy buffalo | Honey BBQ | Sweet Chili, choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch. Served with carrots & celery.
Chicken Fries
$9.27
Chicken in the shape of French fries, served with homemade marinara sauce.
Chicken Quesadilla
$15.45
Served with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, homemade salsa & sour cream • Add Avocado +$4.00
Lump Crabmeat Quesadilla
$24.72
Served with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, homemade salsa & sour cream • Add Avocado +$4.00
Cold Sandwiches
Served with L&T, homemade potato salad & homemade cole slaw • Cold salads served Open-Faced or Closed on your choice of: Potato White, Potato Wheat, Rye, Multigrain, Roll, or Wrap
Shrimp Salad
$20.08
Crabmeat Salad
$26.78
Lump crabmeat.
Chicken Salad
$16.48
Tuna Salad
$16.48
Combination Salad
$27.81
Choice of 2: Crabmeat | Chicken | Tuna | Shrimp
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
$12.87
Ham & Cheese
$12.36
Turkey & Cheese
$12.36
Turkey Club
$16.48
Burgers
All burgers served with lettuce, tomato, and pickles • Add Cheese +$0.75: American | Swiss | Cheddar | Mozzarella | Melted Bleu Cheese +$0.77 • Add Bacon +$1.06 • Deluxe Additions +$4.63: French Fries | Cajun Fries | Onion Rings | Sweet Potato Fries +$4.77
Hamburger
$13.39/8 oz
Turkey Burger
$15.48/5 oz
Plant-Based Burger
$12.36
Meatless burger tastes like a burger, but it’s made from plants.
From the Grill
Additions +$4.63: French Fries | Sweet Potato Fries | Cajun Fries | Onion Rings | Homemade Potato Salad | Homemade Cole Slaw
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$6.18
Grilled Cheese with Ham or Bacon
$7.21
Hot Dog
$4.12
Add Sauerkraut +$0.77
Chicken Fingers
$13.39
Flounder on a Roll
$15.45
Broiled or Fried • Served with lettuce and tomato
Chicken Cutlet on a Roll
$13.39
Grilled or Fried • Served with lettuce and tomato
Seaside Specials
Served with garlic bread
Surf & Turf
$52.53
12 oz. top end sirloin & 3 shrimp oreganta & choice of one side.
Chilean Sea Bass
$44.29
Any style, with a choice of one side.
Sea Scallops Casino
$43.26
Sauteed in garlic butter sauce with bacon and seasoned breadcrumbs and choice of one side.
Seafood Paella
$45.32
Seafood medley of shrimp, mussels, salmon, crabmeat, sausage, beans, and rice in a spicy tomato sauce.
Seafood Rigatoni
$45.32
Four jumbo shrimp, sea scallops, and crabmeat in a creamy bleu cheese sauce.
Seafood Fra Diavlo
$47.38
Red or White | Clams, mussels, shrimp, sea scallops, calamari over linguini
Linguni with Clams
$32.96
Red or White | Mixed with freshly shucked whole and chopped clams
Lobster
Served with garlic bread and your choice of one side
Live Lobster
MKT
Starting at 2 lbs, Steamed or Broiled • Add Crabmeat Stuffing +$7.00
Broiled Lobster Tail
$35.00/8 oz
Add Crabmeat Stuffing +$5.50
Nicky’s Loaded Lobster Roll
With French fries on a toasted bun
Overloaded Fresh Real Lobster Salad
MKT
Warm Lobster with Drawn Butter
MKT
Soft Shell Crab
Fried or Sauteed • Seasonal
Crab on a Roll
MKT
With lettuce & tomato.
2 Crabs
MKT
With choice of 1 side.
3 Crabs
MKT
With garlic bread and choice of 1 side.
Entrees
Served with garlic bread & your choice of one side
SEA LOVERS:
Broiled Flounder
$33.00
Served with garlic, butter & paprika.
Stuffed Flounder
$36.00
Stuffed with snow crabmeat.
Stuffed Shrimp (5)
$43.00
Stuffed with snow crabmeat.
Shrimp Scampi (6)
$40.00
Broiled Flounder Oreganata
$34.00
Garlic bread crumbs.
Jumbo Shrimp Oreganata
$41.00
Broiled with garlic bread crumbs.
Seafood Au Gratin
$42.00
Crabmeat, lobster meat & 2 jumbo shrimp in a creamy white sauce with melted cheddar jack cheese.
Fresh Sesame Seared Tuna
$41.00
Served with seaweed salad, teriyaki ginger sauce & wasabi.
Broiled Seafood Oreganata Combo
$43.00
2 shrimp, sea scallops, salmon & flounder.
Fried Whole Belly Top Neck Clams
$32.00
Fried Oysters
$36.00
Fried Bay Scallops
$32.00
Fried Flounder
$35.00
Fried Shrimp (6)
$41.00
Fried Coconut Shrimp (5)
$41.00
Fried Combination Platter
$43.00
Bay scallops, oysters, clams, flounder & 2 jumbo shrimp.
Shrimp Parmigiana (5)
$41.00
Flounder Parmigiana
$35.00
Fried Calamari
$30.00
LAND LOVERS:
Steak Dinner
$44.00/12 oz
Top-end sirloin, Marinated or Plain with crispy onions.
Chicken Parmigiana
$32.00
Chicken Marsala
$32.00
Chicken Francese
$32.00
Sides
Fresh Corn on the Cob
$5.50
Spinach
$7.75
Broccoli
$7.75
Broccoli Rabe
$7.75
Asparagus
$7.75
Baked Potato
$5.50
Rice
$5.50
Garlic Bread
$4.50
Cajun Fries
$7.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$7.00
French Fries
$6.00
Onion Rings
$7.00
Homemade Cole Slaw
$5.50
Homemade Potato Salad
$5.50
Pasta
$6.00
Choice of: Butter | Garlic & Oil | Homemade Marinara
Side Mixed Green Salad
$7.00
Little Sailor’s Fare
For children 10 & under • Meal includes: Juice, Soda or Milk and ice cream
Fried Flounder with French Fries
$13.95
Pasta with Marinara or Butter
$13.95
Grilled Cheese & French Fries
$13.95
Jumbo Fried Shrimp (2) with French Fries
$15.95
Hot Dog with French Fries
$13.95
Hamburger or Cheeseburger with French Fries
$13.95
Chicken Fingers with French Fries
$13.95
Mozzarella Sticks with French Fries
$13.95
Chicken Fries with French Fries
$13.95
Homemade Mac & Cheese
$13.95
Menu
Nicky's Famous Homemade Cinnamon Donut Alamode
$6.18
When available • Add your choice of syrup drizzeld over the top (Raspberry, Chocolate, Caramel)
Velvety Key Lime Pie
$10.30
Creme Brulee Cheesecake
$12.36
Flavor of the day.
Creamy Rice Pudding
$7.21
Home Baked Pies
$7.21/+
Assorted Flavors $7.21| Try Alamode Vanilla or Chocolate $1.03
Volcano with Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream
$12.36
Hot Fudge Sundae with Walnuts
$10.30
Cinnamon Monkey Bread with Vanilla Ice Cream
$16.48
Sharing dessert
Carrot Cake
$10.30
Cup of Ice Cream
Vanilla / Chocolate
Specialty Desserts
Hot Molten Chocolate Cake
$12.36
Filled with fudge topped with your choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Ice cream.
Hot Fudge Sundaes
$8.24/+
With Walnuts $8.24 | Add Bananas $9.27
Warm Cinnamon Monkey Bread
$16.48
Family Style | With Vanilla Ice cream.
Carrot Cake
$10.30
Drinks
Cappuccino
$7.21
Espresso
$7.21
Liquor Coffee
$13.39
Spiked Iced Coffee
$16.48
Frangelica, Baileys, Kahlua, Coffee Served over Ice toppped With whipped cream and caramel.